Review – Action Comics #900


Bookmark and Share

Action Comics #900Much has been said in the last few days of this monumental nine hundredth issue of one of the most pivotal comics in history, Action ComicsAction Comics #900 is a huge leap and massive comic, boasting 96 pages and a cover price of $5.99.  I won’t delve into the controversy for now, expect that in an hour, instead how is the comic?

Paul Cornell, Damon Lindelof, David Goyer, Geoff Johns, Paul Dini and Richard Donner are just some of the names that make this a pretty solid issue, if not a bit uneven.

Paul Cornell, Pete Woods and Jesus Merino (and a few others) continue the main story running through the series, The Black Ring.  Basically, Lex is now God and Superman confronts him.  It’s very much Star Trek V: The Final Frontier and the story is about as good as the movie.  As a whole, there’s a lot of plot points that either don’t make sense or belittles Lex Luthor as a villain and character.  It could also be the fact that I haven’t read the lead up.  I’m sure that didn’t help.

The short stories that followed are a mix bag.  Each has a point and attempts to analyze a different facet of the Superman character and mythos in a different way.

Damon Lindelof and Ryan Sook‘s entry gives us a few days before the end of Krypton.  It’s the highlight of the issue with just a touching simple story.  One that makes you think, and gives you a moment of pause.

Geoff Johns and Gary Frank is the weakest of stories featuring the Legion of Super Heroes.  If you don’t know these characters, like me, this will go over your head.

Paul Dini and RB Silva’s story is the one that gets you to think about an alien who’s the last of it’s kind and must keep what it’s scene going.  A nice reflection to Superman.

David Goyer and Miguel Speulveda bring us the news worthy story that has Superman heading to Tehran and partaking in a rally in Iran.  This causes controversy and an international incident as it looks like the US is interfering with their internal affairs.  It results in Superman making a bold statement about his citizenship.  The story is one of the two stand out as it features real world locations, unlike previous stories which usually feature an echo.

Finally Richard Donner, Derek Hoffman and Matt Camp present a Superman story in screenplay format, which is always neat to see.

Overall the issue is mixed.  The main story I could do without, but the rest, minus Johns’, are pretty solid stuff.  If nothing else, grab it to see what the controversy is about.

Plot:  The stories are mixed with the main one falling short for me and Lindelof’s and Goyer’s standing out.  The rest are ok, and entertaining, but I can’t say it makes me think I’ve been missing much when it comes to Superman stories.  The individual stories have various scores but the average is… Rating: 8.25

Art:  The art is all over the place and none of it blows me away like some previous artists I remember.  I think the characters are often inconsistent in some of the stories.  It’s all good work, but definitely not what I envisioned.  Rating: 7.5

Overall:  The issue is making news and there’s a lot there, much of it is cool.  I definitely think it’s worth the purchase, there’s two stories that give you pause to think.  We’ll see if one of them is carried forward, because if it is, that’s a Superman series I’d want to buy.  Overall rating: 8

Recommendation: Buy

Page count: 96 pages    Price: $5.99    Release Date: 4/27/2011

DC Comics provided Graphic Policy with an advance copy of this issue for FREE for review.