Mini Reviews: Batman & Robin: Year One, Godfather of Hell, Avengers Assemble, and Mystique
Sometimes, the staff at Graphic Policy read more comics than we’re able to get reviewed. When that happens you’ll see a weekly feature compiling reviews of the comics, or graphic novels, we just didn’t get a chance to write a full one for.
These are Graphic Policy’s Mini Reviews and Recommendations.
Logan
Mystique #1 (Marvel) – Of course, a character who can change form in every panel makes for a compelling comic. Cartoonist Declan Shalvey turns in a comic that has Raven Darkholme searching for a mysterious MacGuffin in the ashes of SHIELD and Krakoa with new CIA mutant liaison Nick Fury Jr. hot (Or not so hot) on her heels. The whole comic is an action-packed cat and mouse game with some fun layouts from Shalvey like a double page spread with different central character on each panel. Throw in a heart-breaking final page and emotional moments between Nick Fury Sr and Jr, and Mystique #1 is a fine and unique addition to the X-line. Overall: 7.8 Verdict: Buy
Avengers Assemble #2 (Marvel) – Steve Orlando, Scot Eaton, Elisabetta D’Amico, and Sonia Oback‘s Avengers Assemble #2 continues the formula of standalone mission with a side of character development for the teammates not on the mission plus the growth of a larger threat. I love how Orlando writes banter for the Avengers with Night Thrasher getting all the best lines as he verbally spars with Hawkeye while trying to figure out what to do with some ghost apes. This mission isn’t just punching, but Cap must demonstrate his leadership skills and figure out why intelligent ape ghosts are terrorizing a small Massachusetts town. Eaton and D’Amico nail the multiple crowd scenes, and Avengers Assemble keeps scratching that old school team comic itch. Overall: 8.0 Verdict: Buy
Godfather of Hell #1 (Vault) – Godfather of Hell is a stylish supernatural crime comic from Cavan Scott, Pius Bak, and Raul Angulo. A mob enforcer named Dario has a pang of conscience at the wrong time, gets whacked, and goes to Hell where he’s haunted by the disgusting forms of his kills. However, he has a skill set that the demon Samael likes so he gets a kind of anti-redemption second chance. Bak and Angulo bring a flashing colors, kind of gonzo sensibility to the art with small panels that show how much Dario has compromised himself in his life. Scott’s script is a cross between Karen Berger’s Vertigo books and Axel Alonso’s crime ones he edited before going to Marvel so there’s a little bit of nostalgic feel to the comic while also being something new. Overall: 8.1 Verdict: Buy
Batman and Robin Year One #1 (DC) – If Absolute Batman was revisionist, then Batman and Robin Year One #1 is vintage Batman at its finest from Mark Waid, Chris Samnee, Mat Lopes, and Clayton Cowles. Skipping the death of Dick Grayson’s parents, this comic explores the early days of the partnership between Batman and Robin. Like previous “Robin Year One” type stories, the villain they face is Two-Face, but he’s just the herald to a greater evil. It’s only the first issue so I don’t want to be quick to judgment, but the “new villain in town” angle is a little overused. We’ll see if he’s the formidable threat that Two-Face proclaimed. However, Batman and Robin Year One has some pronounced strengths, including three-dimensional characterization for both leads and even Two-Face who has a different speaking and facial expression style depending on what side of his face is talking. However, the real reason to pick up this book is Samnee’s visuals. The car chases, splash pages, and high-flying action is a give-in, but Chris Samnee is truly the master of the beat panel: adding tension and/or humor to what would usually be a basic interaction like Batman ghosting Commissioner Gordon. It’s fun seeing his and Waid’s take on such an iconic character, and this is a must-read especially for fans of Batman: The Animated Series. Overall: 8.5 Verdict: Buy
































