TV Review: Gotham S4E1 A Dark Knight: Pax Penguina
Detective Gordon suspects that Jonathan Crane has resurfaced; Penguin hosts the grand opening of his new Iceberg Lounge; Bruce begins his vigilante watch.
Gotham has returned with a mix of an episode that picks up where last season left off. Bruce is well on his way to becoming Batman and Penguin is making his moves to take over the city… in a way. There’s good and bad in this episode, a lot of good actually and that’s a bit surprising based on the promotional material leading up to this season.
I’ll start with the bad. As usual it’s everything having to do with Bruce Wayne and his becoming a vigilante. It’s hard to ignore that he’s maybe 15 or 16 and there’s little push to stop him from doing what he’s doing. There’s also the fact he’s either really good or really bad at everything he’s doing. He either trips and stumbles into a fight or is able to disappear like a ghost. He confronts Penguin and in a rather awkward exchange it’s clear he’s investigating the new set up I’ll discuss more below.
All of the above isn’t helped by the fact that David Mazouz still hasn’t grown as an actor. Everything is delivered in a bland, boring, monotone way. When everyone else is so full of life, it stands out, especially when actor Sean Pertwee is so good in everything he does as Alfred.
Lets get to the rest of the episode though….
There’s a new status quo in Gotham and now all crime is being licensed through Penguin’s associates with the blessings of those in charge like the head of the police and Mayor. It’s a head scratcher that would work a bit better if it wasn’t so blunt and out there. Everyone knows about this and the Feds haven’t stepped in?
What’s good about the storyline is that it dials back the villains focus which was escalating and getting a bit silly. Instead it’s more mob vs police and a focus on corruption grounding things a bit. But, the cat’s out of the bag so there’s still colorful characters like Mr. Freeze and Poison Ivy and the Riddler (on ice). The episode is the strongest when it focuses on the police and their dealing with this new status quo. Bullock and Gordon especially stand out and have through the series. It just gets derailed when things shift towards Bruce.
So, the first episode sets things up but it’s a mixed bag. There’s glimpses of a solid series and then things get silly again showing those behind the series don’t seem to know exactly what type of series they’re doing. Hopefully we get more of the Gotham police and a little less of masks and cowls.
Overall Rating: 7.0







With the deadly virus spreading throughout the city, the search for the antidote continuesl Fish Mooney, The Riddler, and Penguin reveal plans of their own; Bruce meets Ra’s Al Ghul and completes his task; Gordon tries to win back Lee.
After Charlotte accidentally charbroils a man to death in self-defense, Lucifer tries to hide it from Chloe; Maze goes looking for Charlotte and Amenadiel; Lucifer tries to find a permanent solution for the ticking time bomb he calls Mom.