Tag Archives: the shadow

Review: Batman/The Shadow #2

The combination crossover/murder mystery/exploration of Batman’s debt to The Shadow in pop culture continues in Batman/The Shadow #2. The big reveal in the previous is that Henri Ducard, Batman’s mentor and Liam Neeson’s character in Batman Begins, was one of many civilian identities that The Shadow took on to strike out at evil. Artist Riley Rossmo and colorist Ivan Plascencia continue to draw The Shadow more like a force nature than a man throughout the comic, and Batman seems clumsy and unwieldy in the face of his supernatural opponent and former mentor.

The main highlight of Batman/The Shadow #2 is Rossmo continuing to draw The Shadow like a gun toting, will-o’-the-wisp, but Scott Snyder and Steve Orlando have also plotted a hell of decades spanning, complex, yet archetypical mystery. The Shadow deals in absolute good and evil, and that is why his nemesis, the Stag, is preying on the “best” people of Gotham, including Leslie Thompkins. Also, with the death of Lamont Cranston, he lacks a connection to humanity. By trotting out the wizened, old versions of his “agents”, including love interest Margot Lane, Snyder, Orlando, and Rossmo show that The Shadow is a manipulative bastard, who only had relationships with people to further his war on crime. Batman has acted this way sometimes too, like in Snyder and Greg Capullo’s “Death of the Family” storyline in Batman, and it’s interesting to see him be used by The Shadow as a kind of tour guide in Gotham to track down The Stag yet again.

There is an anarchic energy to Rossmo and Plascencia’s art in Batman/The Shadow #2, and it’s the furthest thing from superhero house style. Rossmo plays with the supernatural of the Shadow by making him barely fill out the edges of a panel and then having him collide into Batman like their opening hand to hand battle. His line is stronger any time there is the scene in the present or any kind of corporeal action while Rossmo uses a looser style for flashbacks, like Batman questioning the Shadow about the different identities and people he’s slain over the years. With his predominantly dark grey palette, Ivan Plascencia is a perfect choice for these two dark vigilantes even if the first splash page featuring The Shadow has a run of crimson too.

Batman/The Shadow continues to be the dark double of the classic “Beware the Gray Ghost” episode of Batman: The Animated Series where Batman meets Gary Trent, his childhood hero. Whereas that episode had a rose-colored, nostalgic view of the pulp heroes that inspired modern superheroes, Batman/The Shadow shows that these characters were intense and often disturbed. Batman may be a creature of the night, but after his early appearances in the 1930s, he never capped criminals in the head like The Shadow. They aren’t essential to the plot, but Batman’s conversations with Alfred, who he treats as a friend, ally, and not some disposable weapon, make his humanity shine. Along with Rossmo’s close-up of him dropping a bowl of soup when he hears that Leslie is in danger, it shows that Batman has friends and wants to help them instead of just following an obsessive quest to wipe out evil like The Shadow.

Scott Snyder, Steve Orlando, Riley Rossmo, and Ivan Plascencia continue to explore Batman’s violent, supernatural, and handgun wielding past in Batman/The Shadow #2. Except they add a twisting, turning mystery and an idiosyncratic art style to the mix so there’s a little for everyone in this intercompany crossover. There’s also just a touch of the old school pulps in the comic, like the swashbuckling duel between Batman and “Ducard” that opens the story.

Story: Scott Snyder and Steve Orlando Art: Riley Rossmo Colors: Ivan Plascencia
Story: 8 Art: 8.5 Overall: 8.3 Recommendation: Buy 

DC Comics provided Graphic Policy with a FREE copy for review

Mini Reviews for the week ending 12/12/15

Sometimes, the staff at Graphic Policy read more comics than we’re able to get reviewed. When that happens you’ll see a weekly feature compiling short reviews from the staff of the comics, or graphic novels, we just didn’t get a chance to write a full review for. These are Graphic Policy’s Mini Reviews.


Alex

Batman #47Batman #47* I could do with less Jim Gordon and more Bruce Wayne, if I’m being honest, but this was a solid comic. There’s certainly a crescendo we’re building toward here, and it’s gong to be glorious when it breaks. Overall: 8.5 Recommendation: Buy

The Shadow #5 was a fairly decent ending to a story that, for the most part was pretty good. And I think that’s the problem here; the story arc was good, but it could have been better.Overall: 8 Recommendation: Read

The Precinct #1. Steam punk, cops and magic. It’s a great combination. Overall 8.75 Recommendation Buy

Heroes Vengeance #3 Yeah, it’s okay. I’m losing more interest issue by issue, which is a shame because this started off very strongly. Still, it’s worth a read – for now. Overall: 6.75 Recommendation: Read

The Troop #1 was an entertaining read. Starting a new superhero universe largely from scratch is never easy, but this one shows promise. It’s got the feel of early X-Men comics, but much less innocent, and in a much darker setting. Well worth checking out. Overall: 8 Recommendation: Read

 

Brett

Street Fighter Unlimited #1 (Udon Entertainment) – I haven’t read a Street Fighter comic in a long time, and appreciate the video game series (though wasn’t very good at it). This comic series feels like an extension of the video games series in a good way, a great adaptation, which is something that completely caught me off guard. You usually don’t see this quality in a video game comic adaptation. The story is solid, focusing on Ryo and the dark energy within him. You don’t need to know the greater Street Fighter world, again a good thing, to enjoy this first comic, everything is laid out perfectly for new and old fans alike. An absolute must get, can’t wait to see what comes down the road. Overall: 9 Recommendation: Buy

 

Elana

Monstress_02Gotham Academy #13*: I miss Karl Kerschl’s art a lot. Adam Archer’s art style is cartoony but I find it unattractive but I will give him this: the characters of color are clearly drawn with distinctive features. Colorist Serge LaPointe does a great job with skin tones in particular. In a medium where everyone ends up looking white, even when they aren’t, touches like this are really important. Interesting character development here too. Overall 8 Recommendation: Buy

Angela Queen of Hel #2*: It just keeps getting better. I love how the comic is handling the romantic relationship between our two female leads. The jokes are killer. Sera (who is the best) insults Alanis Morissette’s song “Ironic”, quotes Pat Benatar and air guitars to Norse Metal. Her answer to “why do you know so much about everything” is essentially “because Bardic Knowledge +20”. Like I said, she’s the best. While the colorist is still making Sera too pale and Kim Jacinto draws her too thin Stephanie Hans nails it every time and her art is always stunning across the board. I’ve also heard that in the future, Sera’s skin-tone will be recolored to be brown as it’s supposed to be. Overall 9 Recommendation: Buy

Monstress #2: The best high fantasy series in ages. Beautiful and disturbing. A fantasy series for grown-ups. Issue 2 fleshes out the world and characters just the right amount and is full of unsettling revelations that feel “earned”. The 25 pages are absolutely packed with story and images you won’t find anywhere else. The costumes in this issue are outstanding. Overall 9.5 Recommendation: Buy


Well, there you have it, folks. The reviews we didn’t quite get a chance to write.

Please note that with some of the above comics, Graphic Policy was provided FREE copies for review. Where we purchased the comics, you’ll see an asterisk (*). If you don’t see that, you can infer the comic was a review copy. In cases where we were provided a review copy and we also purchased the comic you’ll see two asterisks (**).

Preview: The Shadow Vol.2 #5

The Shadow Vol.2 #5

writer: Cullen Bunn
artist: Giovanni Timpano
cover: Butch Guice
FC • 32 pages • $3.99 • Teen+

Two orders of murderous magicians are at war! One faction hopes to steal secrets the great Houdini discovered after his death. The other ruthlessly protects these secrets, and they’ll kill innocent people in order to reach their goals. These bitter enemies can agree on only one thing, the Shadow must die!

ShadowVol2-05-Cov-A-Guice

Preview: The Shadow Vol.2 #4

The Shadow Vol.2 #4

writer: Cullen Bunn
artist: Giovanni Timpano
cover: Butch Guice
FC • 32 pages • $3.99 • Teen+

The secrets of the Last Illusion become intertwined with the work of writer H.P. Lovecraft. What warning did Lovecraft try to pass on to Houdini before his death? Will the shocking revelation of these secrets help the Shadow… or destroy him?

ShadowVol2-04-Cov-A-Guice

Review: The Shadow Vol. 2 #4

shadowvol2-04-cov-a-guiceThis is one of those series that seems to be flying under the radar of most comics readers that I’ve been talking too, lately. Admittedly the first issue of the series was only worth picking up because it was a dollar; if it was a full priced comic then it would have been easy to pass on. But as the series has progressed, Cullen Bunn has settled into a rhythm writing the pulp vigilante, and the quality has steadily increased.

When I first started this review, I was thinking that this issue didn’t quite measure up to the previous one, but I couldn’t think why, so I read the comic again and promptly decided that my first conclusion about The Shadow Vol. 2 #4 wasn’t what I was thinking when I finished the comic the second time.

Especially when I took a look at the work of artist Giovanni Timpano who has some wonderful page construction here with the individual panels blending into the page’s artwork in some truly creative ways; and when you add Mario Lesko‘s colouring work into the mix to give some really solid art. I really enjoyed the way the sepia tones were used for the flashback sequences, which juxtaposed very well with the vibrant colours in the present day which, in the comic, is still at least 70 years ago so we get to see some primitive(ish) technology in action.

The story thus far has been focused on the Shadow attempting to preserve the dying secret of the legendary Harry Houdini. A secret that he has, apparently, passed on from beyond the grave. A secret that nobody except the Shadow knows. The past few issues have dealt with various factions of those hunting the secret, giving each issue a unique sense while still flowing very well into the over all story.

I’ve been a fan of many of the older pulp era heroes from the early 30’s for some time, and I’ve loved Dynamite‘s comics over the past few years featuring those characters, and The Shadow Vol. 2 has been a favourite of mine on the weeks it is released.  Yes, the series didn’t start out as strongly as I’d have liked, but a lot of that was down to issue #1 being the second issue in the series (issue #0 being released several months before), and needing to fill readers in on previous events. Since the initial stumble the series has gone from strength to strength, and if you’re not reading the series now, I’d keep an eye out for the trade.

Story: Cullen Bunn Art: Giovanni Timpano
Story: 8.5 Art: 9 Overall: 8.75 Recommendation: Buy

Dynamite provided Graphic Policy a FREE copy for review.

Review: The Shadow Vol. 2 #3

ShadowVol2-03-Cov-A-GuiceThe Shadow is one of those characters that have been around a long time, longer than most other characters appearing in comics these days, although the character first appeared in the pulp magazines of the early 30’s even providing Bill Finger with a bit of inspiration when he wrote the first Batman story. Unlike Batman, however, The Shadow never returned to the same levels of popularity as he did during his early years.

But he’s just as compelling a character, and this series is a great place to find that out.

The prolific Cullen Bunn has delivered another blinder of an issue here, one that I really enjoyed. As you may or may not be aware I’m a little partial to the older pulp heroes, none more so than the Shadow (except maybe the Phantom), and luckily for me The Shadow Vol. 2 #3 lived up to my expectations.

With The Shadow Vol. 2, Cullen Bunn has been exploring the fascination with life after death, and the possibility of transferring knowledge from the afterlife. The story thus far has been focused on the Shadow tracking down a cabal of magicians desperate to find out what secret the legendary Harry Houdini passed on from beyond the grave. A secret that nobody except the Shadow knows.

Unlike the slower paced second issue, the third installment of the series opens with a bang. There is a stunningly rendered action sequence by series artist Giovanni Timpano that shows off the skills of our hero, both physical and mental, and the work of Mario Lesko really enlivens the scene. There’s a lot for me to love this issue, and the pacing of issue 3 juxtaposes wonderfully against the slower, more story focused second issue. It’s a nice balance that prevents the arc from dragging out. That’s not to say that there is nothing but action here, that’d be wrong, but the comic feels to move faster.

Dynamite‘s current series may not propel him back into the public eye (at least not over night), but it is a series that you should be reading if you’re at curious about the character. This series has been improving with each release, and although I’d suggest you start with the first issue, even picking up issue 2 would give you a fair idea of what’s happening here. The Shadow Vol. 2 just keep getting better and better.

Story: Cullen Bunn  Art: Giovanni Timpano
Story: 8.5 Art: 8.75 Overall: 8.75 Recommendation: Buy

Dynamite provided Graphic Policy a FREE copy for review.

Preview: The Shadow #2

The Shadow #2

writer: Cullen Bunn
artist: Giovanni Timpano
cover: Butch Guice
FC • 32 pages • $3.99 • Teen+

As the Shadow continues his crusade against a cabal of magicians, he comes closer to uncovering the truth behind Houdini’s message from beyond the grave. But the magicians are bringing in a specialist to eliminate the Shadow–an assassin who uses prestidigitation to lethal effect!

ShadowVol2-02-Cov-A-Guice

Review: The Shadow Vol 2 #1

ShadowVol2-01-Cov-A-GuiceWho knows what evil lurks in the hearts of men? The Shadow knows!

The Shadow is a character with a long history that dates back to 1930 when he debuted as a radio program narrator, before finally appearing in print in 1931. Although he has appeared in several comic book series since then, this is the second volume published by Dynamite Entertainment, and contrary to what you may think by the issue numbering, it isn’t the first issue in the series; the story is a continuation of the one told in issue #0 released July 2014.

Obviously, being a first issue this continuation could have been a bit confusing, but Cullen Bunn weaves everything we need to know from issue #0 into a flashback sequence that reminds me of a movie villains confession when the hero is incapacitated. Along with the brief recap paragraph in the opening page, the flashback allows new readers and those who may not remember last years issue #0 to catch up.

The Shadow Vol 2 #1 follows a ruthless cabal of magicians that are searching for the secret to the Last Illusion, and they’ll stop at nothing to achieve their ultimate goal. But the person who knew the most about the mysterious rite is dead, and he shared his secret with one man. Now, the Shadow faces some of his strangest foes as he engages in a deadly game where he might be the hunter, or the hunted. If that synopsis, taken largely from Dynamite‘s website, does sound interesting to you then add this to your pull list. The Shadow Vol 2 #1  is a solid comic book, and although Cullen Bunn gives us a great opening chapter, Giovanni Timpano‘s art work is the real standout in this issue.

Despite the Shadow‘s reputation as a grim vigilante, there is a somewhat comedic action sequence when we first see the eponymous hero; more because of who the Shadow is facing, and the way in which Giovanni Timpano captures the sequence. The hook nosed vigilante is rendered wonderfully here, as well; the intensity of his gaze was almost unsettling to me, and so I found myself almost empathizing with some of the other characters in this issue.

More of a crime noir story that just happens to feature a masked vigilante than an outright superhero story, The Shadow Vol 2 #1 is a good comic book. It’s not quite a great one (although the potential for the story to cross that line is certainly here), but if you’re at all intrigued by the character then it is worth checking out. However, with this comic being priced at a dollar as an introductory offer, then the recommendation below bumps up from Read to Buy. For a dollar you really can’t go wrong with this comic book.

Story: Cullen Bunn Artist: Giovanni Timpano
Story: 7.25 Art 7.75 Overall: 7.75 Recommendation: Buy

Dynamite Entertainment provided Graphic Policy a FREE copy for review.

Preview: Shadow Vol. 2 #1

Shadow Volume 2 #1

writer: Cullen Bunn
artist: Giovanni Timpano
cover: Jackson Guice
FC • 32 pages • $1.00 INTRODUCTORY PRICE! l Teen+

A ruthless cabal of magicians is searching for the secret to the Last Illusion, and they’ll stop at nothing to achieve their goals. But the person who knew the most about the mysterious rite is dead, and he shared his secret with one man — the Shadow! Now, the Shadow faces some of his strangest foes as he engages in a deadly game where he might be the hunter… or the hunted.

ShadowVol2-01-Cov-A-Guice

« Older Entries Recent Entries »