Recap: Supergirl S3E14 – Schott Through the Heart
The return of Supergirl in “Schott Through the Heart” starts off with the team getting ready to go to battle but, it’s not what you think. The team is gearing up for a karaoke battle that is and it is every bit of cheesy awesomeness that you’d expect. They kick things off with Kara doing the robot with spitting some Beastie Boys rhymes and includes J’onn talk singing some Whitney. Since we got off to a happy , fun times start we know the bad things are going to hit us hella hard with the furiousness of a gut punch. The writes did not disappoint in that regard. Winn’s rendition of “Take on Me” is interrupted with news of his fathers death appearing on the news before he gets to sing his first note.
Winn’s mother shows up at the funeral and attempts to reconcile now that it’s “safe” but, the would be heart to heart is cut short when the Toy Makers casket explodes. While Alex is off with J’onn and his dad having dinner , Mon’el and Supergirl have a talk and Winn tries to wrap his head around his father’s exploding casket. Mary attempts to reconcile with Winn but, it falls on deaf ears and this somber moment gets interrupted by “flying monkeys” calling Mary out over the sky of the DOE. When the monkeys finally break through , causing all manner of havoc inside and outside of the building, the team jumps into action , while the winged Monkeys try and take Winn.
Alex and the J’onzz men enjoy an interesting dinner that touches on appropriation and the troubles of black men on earth, especially in America. J’onn admits that while he chose Hank for survival, he kept it because he wanted to live authentically and be seen. We see glimpses that the senior J’onzz might have some form of early Alzheimer’s, either from years of isolation and torture or simple aging. Jimmy and Winn attempt to work through Winn’s emotions in regards to Mary’s return, speaking from experience Jimmy lets Winn know that forgiveness is needed to move forward , if that’s what he wants. For her part, Kara talks to Mary while Mary laments about all the things she wishes she would have said to Winn and Kara lets her know that he just needs time.
Alex and the senior J’onzz have a heart to heart about his condition and he kicks her out when she says it might be best to tell J’onn. It is heartbreaking and real, all he wants is to protect his son and all Alex wants is to protect them both. In other familial relationships, Mary shows off her talents for fixing things while dropping some truth on Winn about what she went through living with his father. Memory is a funny thing and the writers showcase the reality of domestic violence in a very real, thoughtful and non-exploitive way. J’onn confronts Alex to find out why she left and she refuses to let him know the truth in an attempt to keep the peace and protect the men who have become her default dad and grandpa.
Mary escapes the DEO and heads on a secret mission to confront the creator of the flying monkeys to protect Winn. Unfortunately, she does this without backup and gets captured and hostaged for Winn by the Toy Makers apprentice. While his protege monologues her devious plan, Mon’El, Jimmy, Winn and Supergirl head off to save Mary. I love that while running for their lives Jimmy and Winn stay true to character and keep up their witty banter. Mon’El and Supergirl take on a Jurassic robot while Winn uses his wit to try and get away from his fathers crazy protege and with his mom getting physical they are able to take down the villain.
The episode ends with a neat bow wrapped around all of the relationship drama and a feeling of closure. Mary and Winn join the team for karaoke night and finally tells him how happy he makes her and how proud she is of him before he invites her to stick around so that they can really get to know each other. Mon’El and Kara have that heart to heart they needed to have and, in typical Kara awkwardness she thinks the talk wasn’t about his wife but, about the Legions plan. We find out that the third world killer will evolve in 1000 years and the ship didn’t arrive in that time by accident. The J’onzz men finally have a heart to heart where the senior J’onzz admits his condition to his son and his regret at not being able to protect him from the pain and J’onn seeks out Alex, who without words gives him a knowing hug. We also find out why Lana was suspiciously missing from the episode and are left wondering if she’s up to her old Luthor trips again, when we see what’s on the other end of her call to Jimmy.
“Schott Through the Heart” is a decent midseason return for Supergirl. The episode is all about hard talks, reconnecting and relationships , making it one of the more human episodes of the show. There is a real but, touching awkwardness is Mon’El and Supergirl’s conversations that reaches it peak in this episode as the truth comes out. Not to be outdone Winn and his mother Mary have a heart to hear but, it’s going to be understandably hard for Winn to let go of some of their pain and come to terms with their estrangement. And, while these softball relationship tests are hard to watch the one that drives things home and hits the heart, is the relationships between J’onn and his father bringing real world problems into our fantasy world and drawing us into the amazing character development that goes into some of the Supergirl characters. Overall this episode was a somber but, interesting watch and relied heavily on character interactions and emotions rather than the usual battle scenes that drive the story forward.
Overall Rating: 8.2