Tag Archives: rumor

Anatomy of Poor Comic Reporting

Yesterday screenwriter Max Landis posted a Tweet claiming that Marvel was getting back the movie rights to Spider-Man from Sony. That tweet was later taken down, and followed up with:

2014-05-14_1356But, before that happened, enough time had passed that the “joke” was picked up as actual news. I first came across my desk with a post from Bleeding Cool bringing up the Tweet, but more questioning why Landis posted it. A few hours after Bleeding Cool “broke the news” Cosmic Book News picked up on the story, treating it as actual news, though hedging their bets, Furious Fanboys reported it as rumor via Bleeding Cool. Cosmic Book News gave credit to Bleeding Cool for the original post. Today, Unleash the Fanboy, followed up on the news, as if it were true, using the screen cap from the Bleeding Cool article, but giving credit to Cosmic Book News. At the time of Unleash’s post, Landis’ admission it was a joke was up for around 12 hours, and the original Tweets deleted. The “news” was also picked up by Movie Pilot (with no credit), Yahoo UK (via Cosmic Book News), MoviePilot (with no credit), and many more. All the ones I looked at failed to update their article with Landis’ latest Tweet admitting it was a joke. Those last three examples were posted after Landis mentioned it was a joke. Luckily some sites saw through the crap, and debunked it like Slash Film.

The initial Tweet smelled of bullshit to begin with, but the fact it was picked up, and treated as fact by so many without 1) Actually going to the source, 2) Having no follow-up (ie just look at Landis’ Twitter feed), 3) Poorly giving credit to the original source, shows the slide that journalism has taken with the spread of social networking, and increase of link bait writing. The want to gain views, has lead to poorly thought out, and poorly researched articles, even ones a day late to the news. It’s fine to question why Landis Tweeted what he did, but to then report it as fact is irresponsible, and an outright lie. It hurts the credibility of the sites posting such information, and in general gives a black eye to everyone who covers the same topics.

We saw an uptick last year in the lead up to San Diego Comic Con where if you believed the internet, Bryan Cranston was Lex Luthor, Paul Bettany was Ultron, Cable, X-Force, Aquaman, The Flash, and Wonder Woman were all getting movies announced. All those sites that reported got clicks, drowning out REAL news. Unfortunately many of those sites continue to post bullshit articles based on nothing but wishful thinking.

By clicking on these “stories” we only encourage this behavior, by visiting these sites, we reward poor journalism. The lesson is, don’t feed the trolls, whether they’re posting to social networks, or the sites that report on them as fact.

Bryan Cranston Denies Lex Luthor Casting

Bryan Cranston of AMC's 'Breaking Bad'

 

The internets have been rife with bogus reports (I refuse to give them the links) that Breaking Bad star Bryan Cranston has been cast as Lex Luthor in the Man of Steel sequel. Well, that isn’t really the case and that comes directly from Cranston. The Boston Globe caught up with the actor, with is currently playing President Lyndon B. Johnson in the American Repertory Theater production of All the Way, which begins previews Sept. 13., and brought it up in an interview.

 

Cranston was asked about essaying the bald bad guy, and he smiled. “I’ve heard that too,” he said. And what about those reports that he’s signed to play Luthor in as many as six “Man of Steel” movies? He laughed. “Six? This is all news to me. I think that maybe my name is bandied about because I’m known to be bald. ‘What bald guy can we get?’ The reality is they can take any actor and shave his head or put a bald cap on him.”

 

So, unless Cranston is playing coy, there goes the credibility of a few websites….

 

Sites Make Up News Others Report It. The Age of Link Baiting.

rumorsA horrible trend has been kicking into high gear in recent months, website completely pulling crap out of their asses and reporting it as news based on “rumor.” Those rumors are based on nothing really other than wishful thinking. You saw this kick into high gear around San Diego Comic-Con this year as numerous sites reported that Cable, X-Force, Deadpool, Aquaman, the Flash and Wonder Woman were all getting movies announced. Of course, none of those were announced, but who knows in the future. In the short term though, those rumors died a sad sad death.

This week though, the bullshit factor kicked into high gear with the “reporting” that actor Bryan Cranston would be playing Lex Luthor in the upcoming Man of Steel sequel. I won’t link to the dogshit reporting concerning this, but it was picked up by reputable newsites all acting as if this was a done deal. Few mentioned that this was all a rumor and no announcement had been made and if they did, that fact was buried behind a misleading subject.

Luckily some sites called the reporting out for what it was, completely made up. The Atlantic Wire, Screen Crush and Comic Book Movie all called out the poor reporting taking those respected sites to task for the bad reporting. While the talented actor might be announced down the road, he hasn’t yet and until an official announcement is made, it’s all people making themselves feel important by playing a game of telephone.

During all of that, Elizabeth Olsen was “in discussions” to play the Scarlet Witch in the Avengers sequel. That too was also rumors and talks often don’t wind up as anything other than a wishlist of actors. That too was reported as a done deal.

Last night, I received an email reporting on another “fact” about Avengers: Age of Ultron and the origin of Ultron and ties to Jarvis. Again, this might come out as true, but it was clear that the site was looking for links and the hits. They outright asked for a link to their story, and if a site did report this, then they should be doing that regardless. But, since it worked for the other not in the know website, it’ll work for this one too, right?

Here’s the short of it, this is link baiting. It’s the new form of “journalism” whose entire goal is to get you to click a link like a mouse trying to get some food by clicking a lever. There’s little truth to those rumors usually, and often it’s wishful thinking or misheard information. The Onion took CNN to task (and really every site) for their reporting about Miley Cyrus’ meltdown.

But here’s the worst part of it all, this actually hurts the rest of us when we report actual rumors that are true based on insider or leaked information, not made up, not wishful thinking. It encourages the worst kind of “journalism” and “reporting.” Being Bob Woodward (look him up) doesn’t involve writing down what you and your friends thought would be cool and passing it off as reality. You’re most likely wrong, and you will be called out.

Here’s what you can do, stop feeding the trolls. Stop posting these clearly bogus posts and stories. Stop visiting those sites. Judge sites on accuracy on what they have to say about facts and reality, not the wildest fanboy dreams they can cook up.

Based on No Sources, Rumors Begin About a Gotham Central Type Television Show

rumorsAbout 14 hours ago ThinkMcFly posted an article with the rumor that a television show is in the works based in the Nolan Batman universe that would focus on the Gotham police department. There were no sources cited or evidence given.

Not much is known about the project but Jonah Nolan is said to be playing a role similar to what Marc Guggenheim is owning on Arrow and Greg Berlanti is set to do on Flash. There is no word on what network the show could possibly be featured on but logic would indicate that CW would be a likely destination.

The lack of source didn’t stop the internet from treating this as fact and articles popped up here, here, here, here and numerous boards. Many of those swiping the header image that appeared in the original source. Few acknowledged there is no evidence this is the case or it is being worked on. Online journalism has turned into one bad game of telephone.

DC has previously worked on such a television series and did produce the excellent comic series Gotham Central.

We’ve reached out to our contacts at DC Entertainment to see if there’s any truth to the, fantastical rumor.

Update: Bleeding Cool reported on and squashed this rumor in late July.