Category Archives: Reviews

Review: Shade, The Changing Girl #2

stcg_cv2_open_order_varSchool is Hell. School is madness, even for the displaced avian Lomo currently inhabiting Earth girl Megan as she returns to Amelia Bloomer High School, much to the confusion of her fellow students. Insisting on being called shade in her new amalgamation of body and personality. Her peers are obviously wary of her, assuming her strange and oddly calm behavior is a result of her accident and resulting coma as she struggles to make sense of her place in the social strata of the school, her relationships with other students and even lunchtime.

Series writer Cecil Castellucci is crafting a strangely off-kilter look at this world through the eyes of her uniquely alien, avian creation Loma. Far more advanced and intelligent then the primitive world around her she none the less has to work to make sense of her strange new home and the people around her already questioning her act of rebellion in stealing the M-vest. Thrown into school Loma has a lot more interactions this issue as we start to learn more and more about Megan’s life. Faced with the tense and confused reactions of Megan’s former friends, unaware the majority wanted her dead. While initially indifferent to those around Loma is still left with the creeping uneasy sense that she’s logged herself firmly into a human with a very complicated and prickly past than she might have first thought. So far there is no sign of the previous occupant, Megan, beyond her memories but it’s such a tantalizing layer to add to an already out there story,  I have a hard time believing that Castellucci won’t bring some of this into the mix during her run.

Being no stranger to writing teens in her long career as a novelist or indeed the criminally overlooked Plain Janes for DC’s last teen-oriented imprint, Minx back in 2008, She has an amazing grasp on writing what feels like authentic teens dialogue and speech patterns without ever slipping into groan worthy cliche or dropping in social media mentions and in fact seems to be actively avoiding this particular pitfall with Shade. The comic slips between this tone and Loma’s more poetic inner monologue beautifully. Ultimately I was left with the feeling that even if the alien elements were stripped out, this series is strong enough already that it would still work wonderfully as a story of identity, change and dealing with the preconceptions others bring into that equation. Working as it’s own unique story even for those like myself who might be coming to the book with only general idea of Shade’s long and esoteric character history.
Matching this with some sensational art  from Marley Zarcone further sets this apart from the rest of the comics crowd, Imbuing the comic from start to finish with its own loose flow and momentum as the story drifts almost lazily and fluidly from one moment to the next. A page featuring Megan getting ready for school shows this in a single panel showing her movement from the room and time, faint versions of herself around the room almost like echoes which emphasizes the books dreamlike qualities and elements of madness. Despite the book’s solicitation saying “No one can have a little bit of madness” the visuals are toned down this issue letting the book breath a  little after the stunning visual spectacle of its debut issue. Subtle and effective when they are used, a small poster here, the madness takes over small parts of her surroundings almost seeping through into the panels.

“I have to study up. Do my homework to really live this life” Shade promises herself setting out her plan for the future as this issue itself does, expanding on the last issue this one treats us to just a little more of Megan’s life, a world that Castellucci makes you eager to explore and learn more about as Loma sets about discovering too. Gorgeous art and sharp writing sets this as a perfect allegory for being an uneasy teen and a story of identity put through a psychedelic, kaleidoscope filter.

Mini Reviews For The Week Ending 11/5

Sometimes, the staff at Graphic Policy read more comics than we’re able to get reviewed. When that happens you’ll see a weekly feature compiling short reviews from the staff of the comics, or graphic novels, we just didn’t get a chance to write a full review for. These are Graphic Policy‘s Mini Reviews.


Alex

bm_cv10_dsBatman #10 (DC) I’m torn on this. There were some cool moments, and the art is great, but there wasn’t enough to make me beg for more. There was barely enough to make me care for the next issue. Overall: 7 Recommendation: Read

Cryptocracy #5 (Dark Horse) A fast paced issue in terms of the plot developments, but we seem to take a little break from the craziness – for a few pages at least. This has been a solidly enjoyable series thus far, but isn’t quite at the Must Read level yet. Overall: 7.5 Recommendation: Read

The Hangman #4 (Dark Circle) The problem with such huge delays between issues is that people forget about the series and don’t notice the finale when it comes out. I missed this last week… and I probably could have missed it this week, to be honest. Overall: 4 Recommendation: Pass

Moon Knight #8 (Marvel)** I’m genuinely torn on this comic. I want to like it, and I do to a certain extent, but I have no idea what the hell is going on. I actually think that I’m beginning to enjoy the series a whole lot more because either I’ve started to catch on, or Jeff Lemire is guiding the plot to a conclusion of sorts. I’ll be back for at least one more issue. Overall: 7 Recommendation: Read

Unworthy Thor #1 (Marvel) It’s been a long time since I’ve read a Marvel comic that I enjoyed as much as this that wasn’t Old Man Logan. Jason Aaron has a fantastic grasp on Marvel’s former hammer swinger, and seeing the god hit rock bottom before getting a glimmer of hope makes for a spectacular comic. Overall: 9 Recommendation: Buy

Joe

the_unworthy_thor__1The Unworthy Thor #1 (Marvel) – I have been waiting for this issue for awhile, and so far it delivered exactly what I wanted and more. The Mighty Thor is one of my favorite current Marvel books, and I love what Aaron has done with it. In this first issue we get a self-loathing but still mead-loving Odinson. He still has his metal Uru arm, and is still sulking about whatever was whispered to him that made him unworthy. We don’t get a ton of answers yet, but we get fighting, biting, Toothgnasher the goat, Beta Ray Bill, a Secret Wars reference, and a pretty huge set up that made me even more excited for this series. The art by Olivier Coipel and colors by Matthew Wilson are fantastic as well. They did a great job fitting the dark and gritty tone of the book. When people say Marvel has lost it, these are the kind of books I point to. Overall: 9.5 Recommendation: Buy

Nightwing #8 (DC) – This has continuously been one of my favorite DC Rebirth titles with every issue. I love the contrast between Nightwing, Raptor, and Batman. This series has been about Dick finding himself, and taking a look at Batman and Bruce as his mentor. With the shocking events of the last issue, Nightwing has to confront not just Raptor, but his past in the circus, his need to be there for Batman, and facing the memories of his mother. This was an excellent issue, and a great way to end this arc. I think Tim Seeley is doing a fantastic job on this run, and more people should be reading it. Overall: 9 Recommendation: Buy

Ryan C

The Flintstones #5 (DC)** – I don’t know how Mark Russell makes this disjointed script work, with have of it being a “present”-day allegory for the outright stupidity of the Trump campaign and the other half being a thinly-disguised Stone Age take on the Vietnam war told in flashbacks, but he pulls it off without a hitch, while Steve Pugh foolkiller_1_coverdelivers his usual solid art. I keep saying it to anyone who will listen — this is the best thing DC’s got going right now, and one of the very best comics being published today, period. Overall: 9.5. Recommendation: Buy

Foolkiller #1 (Marvel)** – Max Bemis and Dalibor Talajic bring back one of Steve Gerber’s trademark idiosyncratic creations, this title focusing on his second (of four, I believe) iterations, and re-introduce readers to the character and concept succinctly and successfully while planting the seeds of an ongoing mystery that promises to be pretty good if successive chapters are as well-executed as this first one. Top it off with a stylish Dave Johnson cover and you’ve got one of the better debuts of the latest “Marvel Now!” re-launch so far. Overall: 8. Recommendation: Buy

The Avengers #1 (Marvel)** – One of the big cornerstones of the umpteenth “Marvel Now!” is the umpteenth relaunch of their purportedly “premier” team book, but this iteration of “Earth’s Mightiest Heroes” is smaller, weaker, and more Spidey-centric than earlier versions, with Parker Industries stepping in as financier/landlord now that Tony Stark and his company are out of the picture. Don’t worry, though — all Mark Waid and Mike Del Mundo have planned is another long-form storyline centered around a fight with Kang. Dull, lifeless stuff right from the word “go,” there’s nothing here you can’t either live without or predict well in advance. Overall: 3. Recommendation: Pass

Shade, The Changing Girl #2 (DC/Young Animal)** – The second issue of Cecil Castellucci and Marley Zarcone’s distinctly “oddball” series leaves dangling many of the more intriguing plot threads raised by the first in favor of an installment that more or less runs in place as our title character comes to grips with her new body and life, but I’m still digging how Ditko-esque the proceedings are in general, and don’t plan on jumping ship anytime soon. I just hope we get a bit more forward progression next time out. Overall: 7. Recommendation: Read

Shean

occupy_avengers__1Occupy Avengers #1 (Marvel): The world’s societal ills have had an impact and activism has recently been increasingly rampant and it would only make sense before some of those issues were examined in the proper scope of comics. Enter Clint Barton’s Hawkeye, Matt Fraction portrayed him as a fun loving , wisecrack who can tend to be self righteous and it definitely remains the standard bearer when it comes to this character . I can definitely say, David Walker has given us a different take that still entertains but as the great KRS-One said ” edutain”, as follow Hawkeye and Red Wolf as they investigate water contamination at a Native American reservation. What the creative team does here , in this first issue, is remarkable, to pack this much intriguing narrative in such few pages with such beautiful backdrops, which makes this , a definite buy. Overall: 10:4 Recommendation: Buy

Bitch Planet #9 (Image)– Kelly Sue Deconnick is at the top of her game since she left Marvel and this series more than proves she is not only a great writer but a great business mind . In this issue of Bitch Planet, the reader gets a front row seat into the mayhem of a prison riot as we find Kam reuniting with Mo and we get introduced to a new leader. We also find out who started the whole riot in the first place and the extenuating circumstances which lead to this . The essays and interviews in the back , is why I will always read the single issues of this series .Overall:9 Recommendation: Buy

Steven

Avengers #1 (Marvel) – Writer Mark Waid drops the ball with this first issue. Writing is vague and doesn’t set up things well. Art by Michael Del Mundo was disappointing, kinda reminded by of a courtroom sketch. I was not impressed by this issue at all.  Overall: 3 Recommendation: Pass

Patrick

Bitch Planet #9 (Image)* – “Order is not justice.” Prison architect Makoto Maki blows the doors open without the slightest idea of what he’s doing. Now not only is there a riot, but a riot in which the various prison populations mix explosively. President Eleanor Doane makes her return… but what kind of authority can she exert in this most toxic of environments? Kelly Sue DeConnick and Valentine De Landro and company are putting out one of the most interesting comics out there. Overall: 9 Recommendation: Buy


Well, there you have it, folks. The reviews we didn’t quite get a chance to write.

Please note that with some of the above comics, Graphic Policy was provided FREE copies for review. Where we purchased the comics, you’ll see an asterisk (*). If you don’t see that, you can infer the comic was a review copy. In cases where we were provided a review copy and we also purchased the comic you’ll see two asterisks (**).

Review: Batgirl #4

bg_cv4_dsBatgirl #4 has Babs on the hunt for Kai. After a major fight with School Girl and Hard Hat she makes her way to Shanghai and gets some primo intel with the help of her BFF Frankie and her hacking expertise. Batgirl learns of Teacher’s sinister plan to boost brain power and she’s the only thing standing in her way.

Hope Larson is a darn good writer and this issue is proof. There’s a real story here that could stand alone and drum up interest for the next issue. The characters are complex and their motives are clear and make sense. There’s a real depth in the story and it’s a page turner that ends with a twist that leaves the readers wanting more.

We also get the bonus of Rafael Albuquerque‘s new school vintage art work. It adds a nice touch the story and each panel is carefully crafted to add to the story. I liked the touches and the toughness that he adds to Batgirl’s face during battle scenes and the images seem to leap off of the page.

Overall, the fourth issue was a good read from beginning to end and brought something special to the current story arc. The main player’s motivation were brought out and well defined. I enjoyed reading it and am looking forward to seeing how this all plays out.

Story: Hope Larson Art: Rafael Albuquerque
Story: 8.7 Art: 8.5 Overall: 8.6 Recommendation: Buy

DC Comics provided Graphic Policy with a FREE copy for review

Review: Deadpool: Too Soon? #1

deadpool-too-soon-1-cover

What do you get when you cross Deadpool, Forbush Man, Squirrel Girl, Spider-Ham, The Punisher, Ant-Man, Howard the Duck, Rocket and Groot? Murder, madness, mystery, and mayhem! Marvel’s biggest WHODUNIT yet!

Given the cast of characters involved in this superhero murder mystery, this Deadpool: Too Soon? #1 is both hilarious and sad at the same time. Despite the odd premise, it is an intriguing read. I’m curious to see how they manage to end this series given how the first issue wraps up.

The art by Reily Brown manages to flow well throughout the issue. Mystery and humor take turns being at the front and center of the plot and Brown’s art enhances it all. Brown shifts between those two atmospheres with ease.

Story: Joshua Corin Art: Reily Brown
Story :8.0 Art: 8.0 Overall: 8.0 Recommendation: Buy

Marvel Comics provided Graphic Policy with a Free Copy for review

Review: Zombie Tramp: Halloween Special 2016

zombie_tramp_halloween_2016-digital-1Zombie Tramp returns to celebrate the darkest holiday of the year, and she’s bringing a murderer’s row of friends and creators with her! It’s an all-new, double-sized Hallow’s Eve romp stuffed with twisted tales, murderous tricks, and tainted treats! Featuring the talents of Dan Mendoza, Jason Martin, Bill McKay, Brian Hess, and many more!

I love the slightly obvious but hidden Easter Egg that manages to present itself in the second tale on this anthology comic. Zombie Tramp: Halloween Special manages to bring in another one Action Lab’s horror-centric characters in a surprisingly amusing away. Yet what stands out for me was the third tale which focuses on Zombie Tramp as creature of vengeance and voodoo in 1950’s America.

Each tale has a different style of art as the three artists bring something different to each of them and the issue as a whole. Some are realistic, some are a-little over the top and cartoon-ish, and it gives the book a an odd sense of balance. It works oddly well since it gives the issue two things. The first is a clear break between stories and the second is it enriches each story in a superb manner making each unique.

Story: Dan Mendoza Art: Brian Hess, Bill McKay, Dan Mendoza
Story: 8.5 Art: 8.5 Overall: 8.5 Recommendation: Buy

Action Lab Entertainment provided Graphic Policy with a FREE copy for review

Review: Intertwined #1

intertwined-001-cov-a-rev

A murder. A mysterious league of protectors operating in the shadows. A legacy to protect. A city to save from filth, corruption, and gangs. A girl who has to pose as a man to protect herself and her heritage. A young Kung Fu student lost in a concrete jungle he never chose to… Welcome to the world of Intertwined. It’s 1971 and for Juan Jin, life is about to become hell! He didn’t ask to be a hero. He didn’t ask to go to Chinatown. He only wanted to follow the way of Wing Chun, the Kung Fu style he masters brilliantly. But destiny had other plans for him!

The first ever Kung Fu Noir series starts here on the heels of its successful campaign on Kickstarter, from Fabrice Sapolsky and hot new French sensation Fred Pham Chuong (who also practices Kung Fu himself)! It’s the creator-owned comic book series you can’t wait to read, even if you don’t know it yet. And it’s from the House of Noir itself, Dynamite Comics!

Sapolsky creates something that hints at so much, yet reveals very little of it. The few things they reveal hint at something big, and something powerful happening with the balance. It creates a heavy sense of mystery, as things get strange for Juan Jin.

The art is a blend of western style and eastern scenery for the most part. While there is a strong sense of flow in the action, there is something that is waiting to be revealed with the plot. I won’t spoil the ending but it will leave you scratching your head I think.

Story: Fabrice Sapolsky Art: Fred Pham Chuong
Story: 8.0 Art: 8.0 Overall: 8.0 Recommendation: Buy

Dynamite Entertainment provided Graphic Policy with a FREE copy for review

Review: Doctor Who: The Ninth Doctor Vol.1 TPB

9d_vol_01_weapons_of_past_destruction_scThe Ninth Doctor is BACK with a brand-new miniseries: WEAPONS OF PAST DESTRUCTION! Leaving World War II behind, The Ninth Doctor, Rose and Captain Jack discover that Time Lord technology, lost in the wake of the Time War, is being sold on the intergalactic black market! Now the threat of a NEW temporal war brews on the horizon, with the Doctor and his friends caught between the twin threats of the Unon and the Lect – two species with intertwined histories who are jostling to replace the Time Lords on the universal stage. Can the Doctor stop history repeating itself? Collects The Ninth Doctor #1-5

Christopher Eccleston’s version of the Doctor was always one my favorite incarnations of the character. Titan Comics manages to bring revive him in splendid fashion in this first compiled volume in superb fashion. The volume manages to bring in the Doctor’s sense of humor about war. The comic is an action filled story involving two fan favorite characters, Rose Tyler, and Captain Jack Harkness.  If you’re a fan of the Ninth Doctor, you should pick this up.

Shedd and Stott do a superb job with the art. The comic manages to showcase unexplored worlds and the dangerous after-effects of the Time War. They give the Doctor a metaphysical grief as he sees what he did after he ended the time war. Only then does the Doctor spring into a flowing sense of action in attempt to right his own wrongs, and try to stem the ripples before they can go farther.

Story: Cavan Scott Art: Blair Shedd, Rachael Stott
Story: 9.0 Art: 9.0 Overall: 9.0 Recommendation: Buy

Titan Comics provided Graphic Policy with a FREE copy for review

Review: Kingsway West #2

29000

In an Old West overrun with magic, the Chinese outlaw Kingsway Law rides toward the town of Rio Chino to reunite with his wife. But can he escape a winged and dangerous Buffalo Soldier scout named Strode and the Engineer’s monstrous posse? Meanwhile, a swordswoman named Ah Toy seeks Kingsway’s help, but every step in the wrong direction is a step further from his love.

Greg Pak and Mirko Colak team up for a magical western!

Violence and flashbacks are two things that can be found throughout the second issue of Kingsway West. The flashbacks give Kingsway an almost human side grounded the story a bit. Those flashbacks manage to give Kingsway Law more depth, along with explains why he wants his wife back.  Even if he has to go back to his old violent ways to do so.

The art, like the story, is violent and bloody. The fight scenes are filled with gunfire and bloody swords. Colak gives it all an almost movie like in that. That focus has the story flow with ease.

Story: Greg Pak Art: Mirko Colak
Story: 8.5 Art:9 Overall: 8.75 Recommendation: Buy

Dark Horse Comics provided Graphic Policy with a FREE copy for review

Marvel Dice Masters: Deadpool: Colossus

marvel-dice-masters-deadpool-colossus-rigid-moralsThis November sees the newest release for WizKidsDice Masters, Marvel Dice Masters: Deadpool. The set is focused on Deadpool’s world including the X-Men and Weapon X, but the set also includes some other familiar characters and the first appearance of the Inhumans team affiliation. I’ll be reviewing a card a day until the set’s release in a few weeks. But, beyond discussing the cards and how they fit into the Dice Masters game, I’ll also focus on the characters themselves and if the card reflects their comic history.

Next up is Colossus: Former Juggernaut and Colossus: Rigid Morals, the common and uncommon version of the card.

Art: Tom Grummett, X-Men Forever #11

Comic origin: Piotr Nikolaievitch Rasputin, aka Colossus, was created by writer Len Wein and artist Dave Cockrum and debuted in Giant-Size X-Men #1 in 1975.

marvel-dice-masters-deadpool-colossus-former-juggernautThe character transforms himself into a metallic “organic steel” form and also is physically strong along with superhuman stamina and durability. For a time the character was the Avatar of Cyttorak aka the Juggernaut!

Born on a Soviet collective farm, he has  sister Illyana and older brother Mikhail.

The character has been a member of the X-Men, Excalibur, an Acolyte, and X-Force, died from the Legacy Virus and been resurrected.

Live action version: The character has appeared in numerous animated television shows and live action films. Daniel Cudmore played the character in 2003’s X2, 2006’s X-Men: The Last Stand, and 2014’s X-Men: Days of Future Past. He also appears via CGI in 2016’s Deadpool. In that film Andre Tricoteux and T. J. Storm provided motion capture, Glenn Ennis provided initial face shapes, Greg LaSalle the final facial performance, and he was voiced by Stefan Kapičić.

Card playability: The cards are expensive to purchase and generally to field though a 1 cost to field and 5A 5D is pretty nice. The ability to deal 1 damage to everyone or 2 to all level 1 characters when fielded is an easy way to clear to board if needed. I myself shy away from cards that cost 6 or 7 like these two.

Card vs. Comic: The two cards don’t quite work for me as far as translating the character to card, but they do if you think about his being the Juggernaut. That’s a character that rolls through his enemies since “nothing can stop him” so in that sense dealing damage to everyone works really well.

Final Thoughts: This could be a pretty useful character, either version, but my play style doesn’t match the high cost.

 

WizKids provided Graphic Policy with FREE product for review.

Review: Shade, The Changing Girl #2

422284-_sx1280_ql80_ttd_High school is pretty terrible to begin with. The angst, the pressure, the hormones… I don’t know many people who actually claim that high school was the best time of their life. Being myself in high school was hard enough. I can’t imagine being an alien in a Madness Vest possessing the body of a 15-year-old girl.

For Loma Shade though, life has gotten that complicated. After possessing the body of Megan, Shade is dealing with the fallout of her new body’s previous owner’s life. While the details are fuzzy on just what happened that caused Megan to slip into a coma in the first place, the details are even more fuzzy to Shade. Bits and pieces slip in, but not enough to form a coherent picture of anything. It’s enough to overwhelm our new traveler as she tries to deal with the Madness for the first time. Something that, if the Ministry of Ministries on Meta is to be believed, can kill her if she’s not careful.

So far in its first two issues, Shade, The Changing Girl is a dense book. It throws you right into the Madness experienced by Shade as she tries to navigate her new life. The balance between Cecil Castellucci’s writing and Marley Zarcone and Kelly Fitzpatrick’s art makes sure of that. However, in the Madness, there is still a relatable story. In the case of this particular issue, it’s isolation. If you were any sort of weird kid in school, Shade’s struggle to understand the politics of popularity as well as her own life and her boredom with the material being taught is a straight blast from the past. Granted, with the extra alien layer, but that’s what makes it so mind bending and great. Part of what makes it so easy to lose yourself in this book is the colorful and twisty art from Zarcone and Fitzpatrick.

Along with Shade’s struggle to adapt to her new life is a web of mysteries that builds on top of each other. Shade is trying to put together just what these people in her life are supposed to be to her. The swim team stays quiet, whispering to each other messages of fear. Megan’s mother Anna struggles to figure out just what her “daughter’s” deal is since waking up. The Ministry on Meta is trying to find the vest while Lepuck struggles to keep quiet about what Loma did. On top of all of this, it appears that Megan’s spirit might not be as dead as originally thought. Uh oh.

screen-shot-2016-11-04-at-8-12-58-pm

With all of that going on, it’s easy to understand why Shade wants to cling to River, but it’s also a good way to keep the plot moving forward. Now we’re in at least three different levels of intrigue as Shade has at least two groups trying to stop her. Not to mention wondering what the newly noncorporeal Megan will do now that she’s not bound to her broken body. If she’s going to be the figure in the wallpaper, to steal an allusion from this issue. This is what really drives this issue. Wondering just what Shade is going to do as all of these known and unknown forces prepare to move in. For her though, it’s less about a potential fight and more trying to understand her new life as she drags an old TV inside after walking home from school for “homework.” Let’s hope she can understand it before the Ministry or the Madness kills her.

Story: Cecil Castellucci Art: Marley Zarcone and Kelly Fitzpatrick
Story: 8.5 Art: 9.5 Overall: 9.0 Recommendation: Buy

DC Comics provided Graphic Policy with a FREE copy for review

« Older Entries Recent Entries »