Mini Reviews For The Week Ending 11/3
Sometimes, the staff at Graphic Policy read more comics than we’re able to get reviewed. When that happens you’ll see a weekly feature compiling short reviews from the staff of the comics, or graphic novels, we just didn’t get a chance to write a full review for.
These are Graphic Policy’s Mini Reviews.
Batman Annual #4 (DC) **- In years past, the stand-alone Annuals have showcased Tom King’s best writing on this series, and that pattern holds true here with this story told from Alfred’s point of view. It would be nice if we got scripts of this quality consistently, of course, but I guess beggars and can’t be choosers, and “Batman” readers are definitely beggars at this point, myself included. The art is a more hit-and-miss affair, with the pages by Jorge Fornes looking stylish and slick and gritty, while those by Mike Norton are a big come-down to standard-issue superhero stuff. Overall: 7.5. Recommendation: Buy.
Batman And The Outsiders Annual #1 (DC)** – I guess if you’re a big Katana fan you’ll have fun with this trip inside her trademark Soultaker sword, but for anyone else, Bryan Hill’s script feels like 15 pages stretched out to fill 40, and Max Raynor’s art looks about as non-descript as is humanly possible. Overall: 2.5. Recommendation: Pass.
DCeased #6 (DC)** – A pretty fun conclusion to a pretty fun, if ultimately disposable, series that sees Tom Taylor put satisfactory, if temporary, bow-wraps on all his plotlines and Trevor Hairsine (and helpers) deliver the goods in fairly impressive “horror comics” fashion on art. The sequel-prep going on is almost painfully obvious, but considering how popular this thing has been, I don’t think too many readers will be complaining about that. Overall: 7.5. Recommendation: Buy.
Silver Surfer: Black #5 (Marvel) – The final installment of this series pretty much fits the patterns of the previous four : Donny Cates delivers a serviceable-if-far-from-memorable script, while Tradd Moore blows the hinges off the doors with his unique and stunning blend of Kirby cosmic and Ditko mystic. Yup, you’re gonna want to own this one for the art alone. Overall: 7.5. Recommendation: Buy.
Marvel Zombies Resurrection #1 (Marvel)– Mr Fantastic intercepts a message where he finds out that Galactus is dead. This causes him to assemble the Avengers and destroy what’s left of his body. What they find is worst, as every Avenger who showed up, gets infected with a Zombie virus. By issue’s end, instead of isolating the contagion, they inadvertently lead the body of Galactus to Earth. Overall: 9.6 Recommendation: Buy
Excalibur #1 (Marvel)– As a fan of the original run of this book, I had my reservations about a new iteration of the story. I am so glad to be so relieved, as this story has many moving parts, that all serve the same master. As we are brought back to Otherworld, this time, in a war, where Morgan La Fey holds the seat of power which reactivates Excalibur with a few members of the X-men into play. By issue’s end, a new Captain Britain emerges, and a fight for the Throne of The Otherworld is at stake. Overall: 10 Recommendation: Buy
Giant Days As Time Goes By #1 (BOOM!)– John Allison, Max Sarin, and Whitney Cogar deliver a picture perfect epilogue to the gold standard for slice of life comics. Allison delves into the difficulty of post-college using Esther and her exploitative publishing job as a case study. And Sarin and Cogar bring the over the top facial expressions and surreal elements as Susan walks around with flames over her head when her boyfriend turns down well-paying jobs to stay with her in Sheffield. Oh, and there’s a fantastic Matrix Reloaded homage featuring “executive editorial assistants” and hugs. Lots of hugs between Esther, Susan, and good ol Daisy. Overall: 10 Verdict: Buy
Well, there you have it, folks. The reviews we didn’t quite get a chance to write. See you next week!
Please note that with some of the above comics, Graphic Policy was provided FREE copies for review. Where we purchased the comics, you’ll see an asterisk (*). If you don’t see that, you can infer the comic was a review copy. In cases where we were provided a review copy and we also purchased the comic you’ll see two asterisks (**).