Tag Archives: legal

Marvel Seeks Judicial Declaration that Kirby Heirs’ Copyright Claims are Invalid

A lengthier post will follow in a bit.
Official Press Release

NEW YORK, Jan. 8 /PRNewswire/ — Subsidiaries of Marvel Entertainment, LLC today filed suit in federal court in Manhattan seeking a declaration that notices of termination of copyright assignments served by the heirs of long-time Marvel artist Jack Kirby are invalid.

Last September, attorneys acting for the Kirby heirs sent 45 notices to Marvel seeking to terminate purported assignments by Kirby of copyright interests in Marvel Super Hero characters such as X-Men and Fantastic Four. Kirby’s heirs are claiming that from 2014 to 2019 various rights supposedly transferred to Marvel will revert to them. The Marvel lawsuit asserts that those claims are baseless because all of Kirby’s contributions to Marvel’s publications, like those of other comic book writers and artists of the same period, were works made for hire, making Marvel the sole owner of the copyrights.

“The notices filed by the heirs are an attempt to rewrite the history of Kirby’s relationship with Marvel,” said John Turitzin, Marvel’s General Counsel. “Everything about Kirby’s relationship with Marvel shows that his contributions were works made for hire and that all the copyright interests in them belong to Marvel.”

Under federal copyright law, works that were created at the “instance and expense” of a publisher during the time Kirby was a creator for Marvel were “works made for hire” and owned by that publisher. If, for example, Marvel gave a writer or artist an assignment to create a comic book story populated with new characters or to illustrate a comic book story with depictions of its characters – and paid the writer or artist for carrying out the assignment – the publisher, not the writer or artist, would own the copyright. All of Kirby’s contributions to Marvel comic books the heirs are claiming for themselves fall into this category.

Marvel editors determined which publications Kirby would work on, just as they did with all the other artists and writers engaged to work on the publications, and always retained full editorial control. In addition, Kirby was paid for his contributions. As a result, all of Kirby’s contributions were solely owned by Marvel, which was standard practice in the comic book publishing industry.

Kirby’s situation at Marvel is completely different from the facts that gave rise to the Superman litigation. The initial Superman story was written and illustrated by its creators well before they had any business relationship with its ultimate publisher.

“The purpose of the lawsuit filed today is simply to set the record straight and obtain a judicial declaration that the Kirby termination notices have no effect,” said Mr. Turitzin.

About Marvel Entertainment:

Marvel Entertainment, LLC, a wholly-owned subsidiary of The Walt Disney Company, is one of the world’s most prominent character-based entertainment companies, built on a proven library of over 5,000 characters featured in a variety of media over seventy years. Marvel utilizes its character franchises in licensing, entertainment (via Marvel Studios and Marvel Animation) and publishing (via Marvel Comics). Marvel’s strategy is to leverage its franchises in a growing array of opportunities around the world, including feature films, consumer products, toys, video games, animated television, direct-to-DVD and online. For more information visit www.marvel.com.

Nemesis Is It’s Own Nemesis


Bookmark and Share

This week has brought all kinds of news about legal issues regarding Mark Millar’s upcoming Marvel/Icon series, Nemesis.  Well, we can add another wrinkle to the tale concerning issues of the comic books title.

Bleeding Cool is reporting that due to DC’s upcoming series in March, Nemesis: The Imposters and Marvel’s own video game Marvel Nemesis: Rise of the Imperfects (which interestingly enough Mark Millar worked on), something needed to be done with the name of Millar’s series.

The series will now be called Millar And McNiven’s Nemesis. Now the question is how much more legal news will spin out of this one series?

DC is Not Quite Millar’s Nemesis


Bookmark and Share

NemesisReports surfaced that DC wasn’t happy about the Mark Millar’s upcoming Marvel/Icon’s series Nemesis and slapped it with some legal wrangling to get it’s cover pulled.

In an interview with Comic Book Resources, Millar says this isn’t quite the case and the reports were blown out of proportion.

According to Millar’s interview with CBR:

In all honesty, the story has been massively misreported.  There is no issue at all here. Someone simply saw that the image we had planned for the first cover had been removed and assumed DC had hit us with a writ or something. Nothing could be further from the truth, and the whole thing is much more informal. What happened was that someone in DC editorial was a little worried that we were casually mentioning two of their characters in interviews and asked legal to ask us not to. The legal guys at DC, who are friends of mine, just dropped me a casual, informal email asking me to be cool, and I agreed, promising them that Steve and I wouldn’t cross any kind of line in the promotion of ‘Nemesis.’

Steve and I both have a good relationship with DC, and I’m friends with about half the staff. So we chatted about it and as a courtesy removed the cover image we planned, which we both felt might just be a little too playful. DC knew this was a gesture of goodwill and appreciated it, but they absolutely didn’t ask us to remove it. Everyone is on very good terms, and there is absolutely no issue here.

DC Is Marvel’s Nemesis


Bookmark and Share

There was something missing from the solicitation for Mark Millar’s next project Nemesis, a cover.  The series is being published by Marvel under their creator own Icon line.  In what has a described in interviews as “What if Batman was the Joker?” was a little too close for a certain other comic book publishing, DC.

Bleeding Cool is reporting that DC has taken legal action forcing Marvel to change the cover for the intended series and left it without a cover for solicitation.  What’s unclear if the legal action will affect the series in other ways or what specifically it entails.

Nemesis

Recent Entries »